Analytics header

Friday, May 10, 2024

OK, lets talk ISA-95!

ISA-95 - How does it fit and what is its impact in the new digital manufacturing paradigm? No need for introductions and summaries of both topics, there is more than enough written on this to cover that. 

Let's start with a reminder that ISA-95 was developed and became a standard a long time ago and both technology and manufacturing has changed since then. It is based on the Purdue Model that dates to 1990s and relies on functional decomposition in general. Therefore at a minimum we should be critical and understand what has changed in order to reflect on the standard - specifically what is still valid and what is not, or needs to be changed. 

ISA-95 attempt to provide a holistic representation of how manufacturing operations should be supported with information systems. Being a standard it offers a double-edged sword. On the positive side it promotes efficient implementation, reduced risk, ease of integration and fosters trust in solution scope. However, standards can also stifle innovation by limiting creative design approaches, and adherence can be costly for manufacturers, especially companies with limited budgets. 

ISA-95 functional model pyramid where lifecycles intersect at operations (from "Beyond the Pyramid: Using ISA95 for Industry 4.0 and Smart Manufacturing", Dennis Brandl)


We have been using the standard for decades and it has helped many companies to clearly define and solve the shop floor control challenge. As such it was mostly used as a reference to define the solution architecture. For solution suppliers it was used mostly to show completeness of their products, i.e. in level of compliance to the standard which helped companies understand what they are getting and what no. The very structured approach that the standard brings certainly helped in effective integration and information exchange. However in the digital manufacturing realm where IIoT and composability is gaining acceptance this presents new challenges:
  • Rigidity: The new paradigm emphasizes adaptability and real-time decision-making. The hierarchical structure of ISA-95 might seem somewhat rigid for these needs. Modern systems favor a composable approach for better scalability and networked IIoT architectures with edge and cloud components.

  • Data Deluge: The explosion of data from the IIoT network of devices, apps, machines, etc. puts a strain on the traditional ISA-95 framework. We need to allow for real-time data processing and analytics at the "edge" (closer to devices) alongside centralized enterprise systems and cloud services. The standard dictates a central Manufacturing Operations Management (MOM) system for data routing. In an IIoT solution nodes communicate at multiple levels in a dynamic networked architecture with edge and cloud components.

  • Gaining Insights: Extracting insights from data is crucial in digital systems and ISA-95 doesn't explicitly address advanced analytics needed to support both the volume and variety of data. It also sets a very rigid structure for data that doesn't lend itself to advanced analytics and AI/ML technologies. 

So Does this mean ISA-95 is obsolete? Not entirely. The core principles of data hierarchy and information flow remain valuable. One of the main thing that I find valuable are some of the patterns in the data models. The core hierarchy concept of organizing data flow into different levels (field devices, automation, operations, and business planning) remains a valuable framework for understanding information flow in a manufacturing setting.  It is not surprising, a lot of experience and time has been put into generalizing how to model production and process and these can be valuable when contextualizing content in next generation digital system. B2MML also provides some valuable insights in to ERP information sharing. But at the same time be warned, use the patterns to add context to data at the source, don't fall into the pit of rigidity and global one size fits all data models.  

So where does ISA-95 go from here (see Walker Reynolds interview Dennis Brandl)? Some advocate evolving the standard but I question the value. Not because of its relevancy but I fundamentally questions if we really need such an overarching holistic standard in the manufacturing operations space. In other words is it even worth the effort? As it stands we can leverage what we need from the standard, as mentioned above, and use these to accelerate adoption of the new paradigm. Let's not reinvent what already works but spend time to build out the principles of flexibility, data management, and openness into specific standards that provide targeted value. There is already plenty of effort and initiatives in this space such Sparkplug B, OPC UA, CESMIIs SM Profiles, Asset Administration Shell (AAS), UNS, etc.

We should also take into account that we are not done transforming. We are in the thick of the shift to the new paradigm and as such technologies are still being developed and some have not yet even emerged. Trying to standardize in a world that is still changing does not yield much. We can however be aware of the standard's relevancy and where if falls short. Focus on the need for agility, the data rich digital systems that are being adopted, and most of all on composability. We have to ask the hard question of the value of a holistic standard when we have citizen developers chatting with no-code systems to create content. So use what is relevant and evolve into the digital realm where it makes sense. Even a Tesla uses standard wheels and tires as a core component, no need to reinvent the wheel there! 

Thursday, April 18, 2024

Skepticism Stifles More Progress Than Failure Ever Does!

Much of what I have written about lately deal directly or indirectly with the general confusion around the topics of digital transformation in the manufacturing industry. I try to bring clarity to many topics such as Industry 4.0, digital transformation, IIoT, etc. and I am seeing a significant change in the industry especially in the last 6 months. Yet, skepticism about the ongoing paradigm change driven by digital technology is still rampant. 

Digital transformation is the engine that propels businesses forward in today's dynamic world.  Companies that leverage new technologies to automate operational activities, improve operator productivity, improve efficiencies, and manage quality are poised to outpace their competitors.  However, lurking in the shadows of this exciting shift is a potential innovation killer - skepticism.  Unfounded negativity towards digital initiatives can create a culture of resistance, stifle groundbreaking ideas, and ultimately hinder progress. Its understandable that new technologies need to be evaluated, and that without proper change management digital transformation can fail. However by being a skeptic you are robbing your organization of potential productivity gains. 

Writing off emerging technologies too soon is a centuries-old practice. New technologies often seem to inspire equal - and often counteracting - surges of enthusiasm and skepticism. 

Sunday, March 17, 2024

Collaboration in IIoT Solutions and the Power of Network Dynamics

In the last blog post I discussed why IIoT is transformative and that IIoT nodes have to be autonomous and collaborative. This post talks about how collaboration, ie communication by sharing of information is a key ingredient for true paradigm shifting digital IIoT solutions.

Imagine a city community buzzing with life where each citizen has their own specialty - the baker crafts delicious treats, the mechanic keeps vehicles running smoothly, and the journalist observes the surrounding landscape and reports on it. But even the most skilled individuals can't achieve much alone. This is where the city's infrastructure comes in - the bustling networks of transport and communication.

So, while individuals hold immense potential (autonomous), it's their collaborative spirit (collaborative), enabled by a robust infrastructure, that truly transforms a community into a thriving, efficient metropolis. Just like a city needs its infrastructure networks to function, smart manufacturing relies on its communication infrastructure to unlock the full potential of its IIoT solutions. There is however a missing ingredient, that is the common understanding of the structure and responsibilities the network of individuals and their roles - in other words a common language and understanding (model). 

Imagine now a factory where an operator using a digital app connected to a machine detecting a slight vibration, alerting a maintenance operator through is app which triggers a task to diagnose the machine. This information then is shared so that the supervisor can use his production optimization app, adjusting parameters on other machines to maintain overall efficiency. This collaboration thrives on a reliable communication infrastructure, the digital backbone of the factory. It ensures real-time data exchange, minimizes latency, and enables seamless coordination between operators and using their apps, regardless of their location or function. 

Image

Without this critical infrastructure and information sharing factory efficiencies are critically hindered. Taking this back to the city analogy - while individual apps hold immense potential, it's their collaborative spirit, enabled by a strong communication infrastructure, that truly unlocks the transformative power of IIoT in smart manufacturing. In the network dynamics of an IIoT solution, communication is the lifeblood of collaboration. IIoT nodes have to actively exchange data through robust communication protocols, sharing insights, experiences, and real-time updates. 

That is why the recent discussion topics about Unified Name Space (UNS), pub/sub, communication protocols such as MQTT, etc. is so interesting. These are technological solution that enable the infrastructure for collaboration. They define the language and common understanding of the factory (model). It is critically important that we understand that the goal is collaboration - that is what makes IIoT solution more productive. With that let's explore some of the core concepts that are needed for collaboration.

Shared Goals or Common Goals

Collaborative nodes work towards a common objective, be it optimizing production processes, enhancing safety, or predicting equipment failures. They understand the bigger picture and tailor their actions accordingly. Imagine a fleet of connected drones optimizing search patterns for an emergency response by sharing real-time information about terrain and obstacles. 

Understanding the business objectives of the manufacturing enterprise is critical and ensuring that all solutions are built uniquely to execute on these objectives is a key success factor. Deming's rule "Create constancy of purpose..." still applies!

Communication capabilities

IIoT nodes must have robust communication protocols to exchange data with other nodes, both within their immediate vicinity and potentially across wider networks. This communication must be based on a common understanding of the factory environment, an interpretable model of the world they exit in. This model needs to include both the equipment (automated or not), the product being produced, materials used, the automation systems and their data, and the humans that operate them. 

In this context concepts such as UNS are a key enabler for communication and therefore collaboration, it is the semantics of the language. Communication protocols such as MQTT are also critical since they enable exchange of information in a dynamic networked environment. MQTT with UNS are the base infrastructure for collaboration and supplemented with an interpretable artifact model as described in a previous post provide the required infrastructure for collaboration.   

Network Dynamics

IIoT networks with their autonomous and collaborative nodes have an emergent behavior that can exhibits intelligence and is highly adaptive. It's like watching a spider web over time. Not only might the spider add new strands or repair broken ones, but the individual insects moving across it create changing patterns and interactions. 

Network dynamics seeks to understand the rules and forces behind these changes, and their impact on the network's overall behavior. It's a paradigm shift, fundamentally reimagining how industries operate and unlocking transformative potential across various dimensions. It is also why IIoT is much more than just the technology being used and more important not all technology enables true IIoT solutions.